| 45' | Bray Owen | ||
| HT | 0 - 0 | ||
| 51' | Johnson Cody | ||
| 52' | 1-1 | Morias Junior | |
| 53' | Cooke Jamie | ||
| 58' | 1-2 | Greenslade Harvey | |
| 60' | Harris WillCooke Jamie | ||
| 60' | Cappello AngeloLatty-Fairweather Thierry |
| 62' | Greenslade Harvey |
| 65' | Bray Owen |
| 71' | Campbell TahvonSims Josh |
| 73' | Campbell Tahvon |
| 76' | Cousin-Dawson FinnPendleton Byron |
| 76' | Jarvis AaronGreenslade Harvey |
| 79' | Harris Will |
| 88' | Jenkins JackHugill Will |
| 88' | Pugh TomKawa David |
| 90' | Cappello Angelo |
| 90' | Turner-Cooke Jay |
| 90' | Griffin JakeBray Owen |
| FT | 3-2 |
| Venue Name: | The Shay Stadium |
| Capacity: | NY |